|
|
||||||||
Invited Review
1 Center for Neurologic Diseases, Partners MS Center, Department of Neurology, Brigham and Womens Hospital
2 Department of Neurology, Harvard Institutes of Medicine, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Harvard Medical School, Boston Massachusetts 02115
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
neural stem cells; experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis; neuroregeneration; cytokines; neural transplantation; neurodegeneration
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| GLOSSARY |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Self-renewing capacity.
This is the ability of a stem cell in vivo and in vitro to generate new stem cells with the same characteristics.
Multipotency.
Multipotency is the ability of a stem cell to give rise to a lineage-specific committed progenitor cell that will terminally differentiate in mature progeny.
Symmetric vs. asymmetric division.
Symmetric division is the generation of two clonally derived stem cells, whereas asymmetric division is the generation of a stem cell and a committed progenitor.
NG2.
NG2 is a proteoglycan, i.e., a marker for oligodendrocyte progenitor cells.
O4.
O4 is an antibody that has recognized a developmental regulated epitope, which signals the first step into terminal oligodendrocyte differentiation.
Th1 cytokines.
Th1 cytokines are secreted preferentially by T cells that have differentiated along a T helper 1 phenotype, including IFN-
, lymphotoxin, and interleukin-2.
Th2 cytokines.
Th2 cytokines are secreted preferentially by T cells that have differentiated along a T helper 2 phenotype, including interleukin-4 and interleukin-5.
Lysolecithin
Lysolecithin is an analog of lysophosphatidylcholine that cause destruction of oligodendrocytes and is used in a model of chemically induced demyelination.
Cuprizone.
Cuprizone is a toxin that targets oligodendrocytes and causes destruction of oligodendrocytes and is used in model of chemically induced demyelination.
Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE).
EAE is a model for the human disease, MS, that is achieved by immunizing a susceptible strain of rodents and primates with myelin antigens.
| BASIC CONCEPTS OF NEURAL STEM AND PROGENITORS CELLS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
There are specific germinative zones in the embryonic and adult mammalian CNS (5) that can be considered as sources of NSCs. These zones include the ventricular zone, the SVZ, the external germinal layer of the cerebellum, the subgranular zone of the dentate gyrus, and the ependymal layer of the spinal cord (77). During the earliest stages of cerebrogenesis, neurons and glia are born in the ventricular zone from NSCs that become progenitors and migrate out using the radial glia as a scaffold to reach the cortex. In addition, radial glia themselves may be multipotent neural precursors with stem cell properties (86, 111, 143, 187). These same NSCs give rise to secondary germinal zones, including the SVZ, that contain a reservoir of undifferentiated, uncommitted NSCs that persist into adulthood (205). In the adult mammalian CNS, NSCs can be isolated from the SVZ, striatum, cortex, and the rostral extension of the olfactory bulb (92). Adult neurogenesis from hippocampus has been observed in humans and rodents during normal and abnormal conditions (64, 194), but the exact cells giving rise to new neurons are still under investigation. Previous studies have suggested that neurogenesis in the adult hippocampus arises from NSCs (64, 276) and that astrocytes from hippocampus are capable of regulating neurogenesis by instructing the stem cells to adopt a neuronal fate (253). These adult hippocampal NSCs are able to generate functional neurons (254). However, these findings have been challenged by recent work; Seaberg et al. (239) showed that the dentate gyrus contains multipotent NSCs during development and until birth, but these cells become restricted neuronal progenitors during adulthood. These results would suggest that what were thought to be adult NSCs from hippocampus were actually contaminating cells from the periventricular region that persist near the adult dentate gyrus and that neuronal restricted progenitors and not NSCs are the source of newly generated dentate gyrus neurons throughout adulthood.
The adult SVZ (153) is a heterogeneous complex of several layers of cells adjacent to the ependyma, surrounding the lateral ventricles. So far, four different types of cells have been identified in the SVZ (Fig. 1, B and C): type A migrating neuronal precursors that migrate to the olfactory bulb; type B nestin-positive, GFAP-positive astrocytes that exhibit NSC properties; type C nestin-positive multipotent progenitors cells (61); and ependymal cells that line the ventricles and the spinal cord and that may have stem-like qualities as well (60, 122, 144). Current evidence suggests that in the adult SVZ, NSCs express GFAP (115). The developmental origin of these cells is unclear; it is suggested that these cells may evolve directly from radial glia, which are multipotent precursor cells that participate in neurogenesis as an anchor for tangential chain migration of neuroblasts (59, 60, 139, 259). Another possibility is that adult NSCs are indeed radial glia that adopt an adult developmental expression of GFAP (115).
In the adult CNS, NSCs of the SVZ divide symmetrically, yielding two NSCs, one of which dies by apoptosis leaving the other to maintain the NSC pool during the life span of the individual (188). During development or when external triggering occurs (such as injury), NSCs proliferate either by symmetric division, where each cell divides into two new NSCs, or by asymmetric division, where the NSC gives rise to one new NSC and a progenitor cell. When asymmetric division predominates, a great number of rapidly proliferating progenitors are generated that migrate out to their final destination. In the songbird (131), NSCs in the adult participate in the neurogenesis that is responsible for seasonal changes of the song. Although neurogenesis has been found to exist in adult mammalian brain, including humans, it is unclear what role NSCs play there, although they do seem to become integrated into neuronal circuitry of the hippocampus, possibly participating in neural plasticity (64, 274, 275) and learning. Impairing the proliferation of endogenous dentate precursors has been shown to affect behavioral learning in the mouse (245, 246).
Characterization and Pluripotency of NSCs
NSCs will proliferate in response to EGF and/or bFGF. This proliferative response can be used to isolate and expand stem-like cells from the CNS. Any proliferative cell grown in serum-free medium without a substrate will form a floating cluster of cells. When such clusters are obtained from primary dissociated neural cultures (e.g., from the SVZ or embryonic forebrain), they may contain and help select for cells with stem-like features. Some investigators who employ this technique have termed this a "neurosphere" assay. When plated on an adherent substrate with serum-containing medium, neurons, astrocytes, oligodendrocytes, as well as undifferentiated cells may appear. It should be emphasized that a single cluster does not equal a clone unless it has been proven to derive from a single isolated cell in an isolated well (1, 53, 55, 59, 122, 171, 188, 280). Self-renewal can be implied if a single cell can give rise to differentiated cells as well as to other undifferentiated cells that can be similarly placed into an isolated well and give rise to all differentiated and undifferentiated progeny.
The above-mentioned maneuvers constitute an "operational" definition of a stem cell and remain today the only valid way of discerning a self-renewing and multipotent NSC. However, surrogate biological markers are constantly being investigated and tested for sensitivity and specificity. Nestin, an intermediate filament protein, has been useful in the study of NSCs (141, 280). Nestin, however, while sensitive, is not specific; it is expressed by a variety of cells that include reactive astrocytes, endothelial cells, SVZ neuronal progenitor cells, and ependymal cells (149, 175), as well as NSCs. It can also be expressed by non-NSCs, such as embryonic stem (ES) cells (151, 158) and pancreatic stem cells (310).
Some investigators have used the low expression of peanut agglutinin (PNA)-binding and heat stable antigen (HSA) to identify a nestin-positive pluripotent NSC from the adult SVZ in mice with the phenotype nestin+ PNAlo HSAlo (228). Multipotent neural progenitor cells from the SVZ may also express the intermediate filament vimentin, the polysialic form of neural cell adhesion molecule (PS-NCAM), and the transcription factor mushashi (242, 304). Another proposed marker is the carbohydrated Lewis X expressed on embryonic pluripotent stem cells and found in 4% of the adult SVZ, but not in the ependymal region. These Lex-positive populations showed stem cells characteristics (41).
Some studies have identified and isolated populations of NSCs based on flow cytometric characteristics in response to uptake of the DNA dye Hoechst: both red and blue wavelengths, similar to studies done in other stem cells (88, 89). The isolation is based on the differential efflux of the dye by a multidrug transporter. The population isolated in this way is called "the side population" or "SP" fraction because the cells segregate to a tiny bin that looks like a small "hook" of cells branching off from the main accumulation of cells after fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). Floating clusters of cells in serum-free medium from dissociated neural cultures may segregate to this SP population (108). Furthermore, the novel hematopoietic stem cell marker CD133 has been used to define a population of human neural precursors cells that exhibit a CD133+ CD34- CD45- phenotype and fulfill all the criteria for human NSCs. However, it is not clear whether these cells are a distinct population of NSCs or simply express distinct markers (273). Other NSCs such as neural crest stem cells (NCSCs), have been prospectively isolated from fetal mouse sciatic nerve using cell surface antigens such as p75, the low-affinity neurotrophin receptor, and P0, a peripheral myelin protein: these cells exhibit phenotype p75+P0- and are capable of self-renewal and the generation of neurons and glia (185). It is most likely that a battery of markers will be needed to define a genuine stem cell. Future work will involve defining the molecular profile or fingerprint of a NSC, much as has been derived for the hematopoietic stem cell.
The term pluripotency refers to the capacity of stem cells to give rise to the full range of cells and tissues in an organism. This most extensive potential was thought to be a specific property of ES cells alone. However, several controversial observations over the past 2 yr have suggested that other stem cells, including NSCs, may have such potential under extraordinary nonphysiological circumstances. NSCs have been reported to give rise to mature nonneural cells (251). Adult murine NSCs may become hematopoietic cells after injection into an irradiated host and express such T cell markers as CD3 (22). Others have shown that, when injected into early stage mice and chick embryos, adult NSCs may differentiate into cells of the gastrointestinal tract, heart, and kidney, expressing markers typically found in these tissues in a nontumorogenic manner (55). NSCs can also produce skeletal myotubes both in vitro and in vivo (79). This behavior is also observed in other stem cells, such as bone-marrow-derived stem cells that after intravenous injection in mice travel to the CNS, express neuronal markers, and generate an astroglial phenotype (27, 178). The purity of the NSC populations used in these experiments as well as the specificity of the markers used to define specific neural and nonneural cell types remain issues of ongoing investigation and inquiry in such experiments. Other groups have failed to reproduce these findings; recently, Morshead et al. (186) transplanted 128 host animals with NSCs, and they could not confirm a contribution to hematopoiesis. An alternative explanation to the Bjornson experiment (22) is that fusion rather than true transdifferentiation may explain some of the extraordinary claims of pluripotency of NSCs (264, 299). In support of this explanation is the recent observation of bone-marrow-derived cells fused to human Purkinje neurons after bone marrow transplantation (284).
Regardless of how confirmatory experiments for the above-cited studies turn out, the differentiation potential of stem cells, including NSCs, remains quite extraordinary. Their ability to differentiate in response to specific environmental clues, both physiological and nonphysiological, suggests a critical role for cytokines and cell-to-cell contact signals and the relative levels of transcription factors on stem cells. For example, the oct-4 gene defines pluripotency and self-renewal of ES cells (198); however, it is downregulated when ES cells change to nestin-positive stem cells (158), suggesting that different "master" transcription factors may regulate pluripotency of NSCs. Terminal differentiation likely depends upon the spatiotemporal expression and interactions of multiple cytokines with their receptors on the NSC surface that activate specific transcriptional programs (235, 271).
Oligodendrocyte Progenitor Cells
In the mature CNS, oligodendrocytes are terminally differentiated cells, yet new oligodendrocytes seem to originate from OPCs (probably by way of NSCs) (99) since there is production of new oligodendrocytes in the adult forebrain (293) and spinal cord (107). OPCs can be identified by several markers: the ganglioside GD3; the cell surface marker A2B5; the O4 antigen; 14F7 monoclonal antibody (301); the glycoprotein AN2 (196); the spliced form of 2',3'-cyclic nucleotide 3'-phosphohydrolase (CNPase) (302); the transcription factors Olig-1, Olig-2, Nkx2.2, Dlx2 (155, 222); and the integral membrane proteoglycan NG2 (142, 197). Although NG2 may be expressed by macrophages and endothelial cells, the pattern of staining and the complex morphology of OPCs helps to make the distinction (124, 215) (Fig. 2, A and B). Using these markers, researchers have detected OPCs in the adult CNS (226).
|
During oligodendrocyte development, OPCs undergo several maturational stages determined by specific antigenic expression and developmental potential (Fig. 2D). The OPCs isolated from the neonatal optic nerve were initially termed "O2A progenitor cells" (221) because they were determined to give rise in vitro to oligodendrocytes ("O") as well as type 2 (fibrous) astrocytes ("2A") depending on the concentration of serum and platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF) in the growth medium. In serum-free medium they differentiate into oligodendrocytes, whereas in serum-containing medium they become astrocytes (65). These proliferative, self-renewing, bipotent glial precursors were immunoreactive to antibodies against GD3, vimentin, A2B5, and NG2. Adult optic nerve also contains a similar type of cell that conserves some properties of its perinatal counterpart (290).
In the initial stages of development, OPCs exhibit the NG2+ PDGFR-
+ O4- phenotype. These cells give rise to more advanced progenitors expressing O4, which, in turn, generate premyelinating oligodendrocytes that lose the expression of NG2 and gain the expression of proteolipid protein (PLP), and, finally, to mature oligodendrocytes expressing MBP and CNPase (65). Expression of O4 is a first step into terminal oligodendrocyte differentiation (83) and indicates a more committed stage with less proliferative potential (283). Gal-C expression is associated with terminal differentiation and is followed by MBP, PLP, and myelin/oligodendrocyte glycoprotein (MOG) expression (237).
Some of the above-described precursors persist as adult OPCs. These OPCs differ from their perinatal counterparts in several respects: they divide, migrate, and differentiate 34 times more slowly than perinatal OPCs. These differences are likely to be cell intrinsic, but the exact mechanism of the progressive change of potential from perinatal OPCs to adult OPCs is unknown. The cell cycle inhibitor p27Kip1 accumulates as these cells divide and has been proposed as one of the mechanisms leading to the change in proliferation potential (240). Additionally, the levels of cdk2 and cyclin are diminished in adult OPCs compared with perinatal cells; this may account for the proliferative state of adult OPCs (16). However, cell intrinsic mechanisms are not sufficient to explain the dormancy of adult OPCs in vivo; Horner et al. (107) found that less than 1% of OPCs divide and exhibit a prolonged cell cycle (Fig. 2C). It is possible that environmental cues absent in the adult brain but present in the myelinating brain or molecules enriched in the adult brain may influence this behavior; molecules like Notch and Jagged have been shown to inhibit OPC differentiation (282). Moreover, OPCs are regionally heterogeneous in their ability to differentiate; for example, cortical OPCs isolated from postnatal day 7 rats exhibit a slow differentiation behavior when compared with optic nerve-derived cells (216). Despite the biological difference, adult OPCs also share many of the characteristics of the perinatal OPCs, such as response to growth factors, the triiodothyronine (T3)-dependent timing for differentiation, and maintenance of their self-renewing capacity (Table 1). Adult OPCs, which can yield mature oligodendrocytes in the adult brain, express NG2, the PDGF
receptor, O4, and the FGF receptor (145). They also express c-kit, a marker for hematopoietic stem cells that is lost when they differentiate into post-mitotic oligodendrocyte (112).
|
-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazole propionate (AMPA) receptor (208), the cell cycle inhibitor p27Kip1 (44), and Notch. Activation of the Notch receptor on OPCs blocks their oligodendrocyte differentiation in the developing optic nerve (282). Because of their abundance in the CNS and the fact that their processes contact the nodes of Ranvier (19), it has been suggested that OPCs subserve synaptic remodeling and plasticity in the adult CNS (199, 291). Recent data, however, point to a broader differentiation potential and replication capacity of OPC; depending on the cytokine milieu, they may exhibit actual neural stem-like characteristics (134, 206, 261).
OPCs express several functional cytokine receptors such as FGF-2R (176) and the PDGF
receptor (225); in fact, as noted above, such receptors have been used as markers for OPCs (218). OPCs have been isolated from brains of healthy humans and of MS patients, and these express the p75NTR (neurotrophin receptor) that is implicated in oligodendrocyte survival and apoptosis (300). In vitro oligodendroglial development can be recapitulated from NSCs; Zhang et al. (306) demonstrated that human oligodendrocytes appear from neurospheres and express PDGF
receptor. The proliferation of these human OPCs was augmented by coculture with neurons and astrocytes (306). Furthermore, human neurospheres increase their yield of oligodendrocyte production when cultured with T3 (190). Finally, control of the timing of OPC differentiation requires extracellular signals such as PDGF
and T3 (63).
| MOLECULAR PROGRAMS THAT CONTROL NSC AND OPC FUNCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
(TGF-
) is also relevant to SVZ precursor cell fate. The tgf-
-/- mice exhibit decreased proliferation of SVZ cells, resulting in a decreased number of progenitors in the SVZ and a reduced number of neuronal progenitors migrating to the olfactory bulb. However, their stem cell number does not change (267). Conversely, intraventricular infusion of TGF-
increases cell proliferation in the SVZ (67). In vivo, EGF and FGF exhibit different effects on NSC. FGF-2 increases the rate of newborn cells, especially neurons, whereas EGF increases the numbers of glia in the hippocampus (136). Additionally, EGF has the capacity to convert type C progenitors (see Neural Stem and Progenitor Cells, above, under BASIC CONCEPTS...) cells form the SVZ into multipotent stem cells (61). FGF is also mitogenic for oligodendrocytes and OPCs (225). The importance of FGF-2 is revealed by the observation that introduction of a dominant-negative version of FGFR1 into OPCs results in cells that are not responsive to FGF-2 and that fail to migrate in vivo (203).
Some members of the ephrin (Eph) family of tyrosine kinase receptors are expressed by cells of the SVZ and have been shown to be involved in the migration of neuronal progenitors in the adult SVZ. The infusion of a truncated version of ephrin-B2 into the lateral ventricle increases proliferation of NSCs and disrupts migration of neuronal progenitors (56). Other developmental molecules involved are the Sonic hedgehog, working through its receptor patched, which regulates proliferation of NSCs from the hippocampus (138); the homeobox transcription factor Emx2, which participates in symmetric division of adult SVZ stem cells (80); and reelin, which facilitates the proliferation of hippocampal NSCs (130).
Hypoxia-induced cytokines such as erythropoietin (EPO) regulate the numbers of NSCs in the SVZ, promoting the production of neuronal progenitors and new olfactory bulb interneurons (244). Other molecules can act as negative regulators of NSC proliferation; pten-/- neurospheres exhibit a greater proliferation, decreased cell death, and enlarged cell and brain size, which may suggest a role for pten in the control of neural progenitors proliferation (95). ß-Catenin transgenic mice show an increase in the proliferation of neural precursors and increase cerebral cortical and brain size, suggesting that this molecule plays a role in the decision of precursors to proliferate or differentiate during mammalian neuronal development (52).
Genes That Control Neuronal Differentiation Of NSCs
FGF regulates the differentiation of NSCs. At low concentrations, FGF-2 induces neurogenic differentiation, whereas it induces oligodendroglial differentiation at high doses (220). FGF-2 requires a novel autocrine cofactor, a glycosylated form of cystatin C that synergizes with FGF-2, to stimulate neuronal differentiation of NSCs in vitro (263).
Presenilin-1 (PS1) is involved in neuronal progenitors fate. PS1 cleaves Notch and induces an activated form that maintains the neuronal progenitors pool. PS1-/- mice exhibit premature neuronal differentiation associated with aberrant neuronal migration and disorganization of architecture of the cerebral hemisphere, due to alteration of the notch pathway (98). Blocking of HES-1, another member of the Notch pathway, results in upregulation of p21, suppression of NSCs proliferation, and generation of GABAergic neurons (125).
Other cytokines are involved in the lineage commitment of NSCs. Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) increases the morphological and antigenic differentiation of neuronal progenitors derived from NSCs (2). Other molecules, such as basic helix loop helix (bHLH) transcription factors, are related to the differentiation of NSCs to glia and to neurons. Neurogenin promotes neurogenesis by functioning as a transcriptional activator and inhibits the differentiation of NSCs into astrocytes by inhibiting the STAT signal transduction associated with astrocytic differentiation (258). Suppressor of cytokine signaling-2 (SOCS-2), an intracellular regulator of cytokine signaling, regulates neurogenesis. SOCS-2-/- mice generated fewer neurons and more astrocytes, and the lack of neurons was related to a decrease of the bHLH neurogenin-1. Overexpression of SOCS-2 increased neurogenesis by blocking growth hormone-mediated downregulation of neurogenin-1 (272).
Hematopoietic cytokines also regulate NSC differentiation. Using immortalized hippocampal stem cells, Mehler et al. (173) showed that cytokines that participate in T cell maturation, immunoglobulin synthesis, and hematopoiesis induce progressive neuronal differentiation. The cytokine IL-11 induces the differentiation of NSCs to immature neurons. However, IL-5, IL-7, and IL-9 induce differentiation of NSCs into more mature neurons when combined with TGF-
after pretreatment with FGF-2. These findings may be of relevance in the context of the potential interaction between immune cell-derived cytokines and precursor cells during immune-mediated demyelination and injury (Table 2).
Thus several immune-related cytokines play a role in the proliferation of NSC and progenitor cells. These molecules may be involved during CNS inflammatory pathological states such as brain and spinal cord injury and MS (15). Therefore, these cytokines and chemokines and their receptors may not only be critical for CNS development but also for their vulnerability during neurodegenerative processes.
Genes That Regulate Glial Differentiation
There are several specific molecules that mediate glial differentiation; these include cytokines and transcription factors (Table 2). For example, OPCs express receptors for bone morphogenetic protein (BMP). BMP actually inhibits oligodendrocyte differentiation by OPCs and promotes their differentiation into astrocytes (94, 160). Transgenic overexpression of BMP-4 leads to increased numbers of astrocytes and reduced numbers of oligodendrocytes (87). Insulin-like growth factor I (IGF-I), neurotrophin-3 (NT-3), and gp130 receptor subunit-related ligands induce the proliferation of OPCs and postmitotic oligodendrocytes (14). In addition, different gp130-associated neuropoietic cytokines [CNTF, LIF, oncostatin-M, and hematopoietic cytokines IL-6, IL-11, IL-12, and granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (GCSF)] have differential trophic effects on oligodendroglial lineage (172). Furthermore, the terminal maturation of OPCs and glial differentiation are dependent on factors that activate gp130/LIF-ß receptors, such as CNTF (165). CNTF enhances the proliferation of OPC as well as the generation of oligodendrocytes in vivo (12). These effects appear to be mediated by phosphorylation of the nuclear corepressor N-Cor with its redistribution out of the nucleus into the cytoplasm. N-Cor-/- NSCs exhibit lack self-renewing capacity and spontaneous astrocytic differentiation, establishing N-Cor as a downstream target of CNTF (102). The downstream signaling pathways responsible for differentiation after gp130 engagement involve the STAT family of transcription factors (182). IL-6 and LIF (both of which signal through gp130) modulate the growth of NSCs and progenitors in vitro via a STAT3-dependent mechanism that requires the transcriptional coactivator p300 (193). STAT5 also plays a role in the proliferation of progenitor cells after cytokine receptor stimulation (46). Additionally, IL-1 promotes mitotic arrest and oligodendrocyte differentiation of OPCs (278).
The Notch family of proteins is critical for NSC and progenitor biology. Notch1 has been used to isolate ependymal stem cells (122). NSCs are depleted in both Notch-/- and preselinin-1-/- mice (a key regulator of Notch signaling). These mice exhibit alteration of both neuronal and glial differentiation (278). This work contrasts with many reports suggesting an involvement of Notch in the inhibition of neuronal fate while promoting glial fate or favoring astrocytic differentiation at the expense of neurogenesis (90). Notch inhibits NCSC differentiation into neurons; even a transient exposure to Notch ligands causes an irreversible change from neurogenesis to gliogenesis (184). Chambers et al. (48) studied the effects of Notch in vivo and found that an excess of activated Notch markedly inhibits the generation of neurons from precursors and increases the generation of astroglial progeny. Notch can also inhibit OPC differentiation during development (282) and induces the generation of radial glia that become periventricular astrocytes in the adult (78). Notch receptor activation inhibits OPC maturation and myelination in the CNS (282) and may underlie the lack of neurogenic differentiation of progenitors after injury (296).
Neuregulins are cytokines present in the ventral ventricular zone where they exert their influence on early OPCs. The neuregulin, glial growth factor-2 (GGF2), is mitogenic for OPCs and is able to maintain OPC plasticity by reverting their phenotype to nestin-expressing precursor cells (39, 40). Neuregulins, as well as their specific receptors ErbB2 and ErbB4, are expressed in multipotent neural precursors from the striatum. They can control the growth of neurospheres. Blocking neuregulin activity in these precursors was associated with decreased mitosis and increased apoptosis. During differentiation of these precursors, neuregulin was required for oligodendrocyte development (32). Vartanian et al. (277) demonstrated that neuregulin is necessary to obtain mature oligodendrocytes from OPCs in the spinal cord. Finally, Sonic hedgehog induces oligodendrocyte development and OPC proliferation from subventricular precursor cells (189).
PDGF
is involved in generating (225) and is the principal mitogen for OPCs (262). It can also induce chemotaxis of NSCs (73) and inhibit their further terminal differentiation into oligodendrocytes (262). PDGF
-induced chemotaxis and oligodendrocyte precursor migration of OPCs can be blocked through the chemokine CXCL1 and its CXCR2 receptor (270). Other molecules that affect migration of OPCs are semaphorins and netrins; sema 3A exerts a repulsive effect, whereas netrin-1 has migratory effect, and sema-F appears to have a dual effect (256).
During development, bHLH proteins regulate formation of neurons from multipotent progenitor cells. The bHLH protein Id4 stimulates cell proliferation and blocks OPC differentiation, whereas downregulation of this molecule is required in order for OPCs to exit the cell cycle and differentiate (133). The transcription factor genes olig-1 and olig-2 that encode for bHLH proteins are associated with the development of OPCs, and olig-2 is required for oligodendrocyte and motor neuron differentiation in the spinal cord (155) (308). Furthermore, the onset of terminal differentiation of OPC into myelin-forming cells requires the expression of transcription factor Sox10 (257). FGFR3 has also been implicated in this process; in FGFR3-/- mice OPCs proliferation is preserved, but terminal differentiation and myelination of OPCs is impaired (202). Hormones and histone deacetylase are important in oligodendroglial development: treatment of rodent and human neurospheres with T3 increases the number of oligodendrocytes observed (190). In contrast, treatment with the histone deacetylase inhibitor trichostatin-A decreases the differentiation of oligodendrocytes resulting in lack of progression of progenitors into mature oligodendrocytes (164)(Table 2).
Genome-wide Screening of Neural Stem and Progenitor Cells
The functional genetic programs of NSC and OPC generation, proliferation, and differentiation are being defined. The introduction of global genomic analysis and gene profiling is helping to define novel genes. Geschwind et al. (85), using microarrays derived from subtractive hybridization between undifferentiated and differentiated progenitors, found novel and known genes differentially expressed in the germinative zone and the NSC clone C17-2 (249). Some of the known genes with differential expression in the germinative zone could provide potential markers for NSCs such as PGAM1 (phosphoglycerate mutase); CAL1H (calpactin 1 heavy chain); Hcyclin D2; cyclin D1; MELK (maternal embryonic leucine zipper kinase) (32). There are genes that appear to be also enriched in hematopoietic stem cells, suggesting overlapping genetic programs between neural and hematopoietic stem cells. Among such genes is Cyt28, a novel transmembrane protein member of the secretin subfamily of seven transmembrane receptors (7TM), found in the SVZ and also expressed in fetal liver stem cells. Other genes such as Ku80, and cyclin D1 are part of a common genetic program of hematopoietic and NSCs (265). Although this approach may yield data about novel genes critical for stem cell function, it is possible that known genes that are important for other stem cell populations, such as cytokine and chemokine receptors, may also be functionally expressed in these cells. Recently, two groups have independently defined the transcriptional profile of several stem cells trying to define the "stemness" by enrichment of genes expressed on several stem cells compared with their mature progeny using Affymetrix microarrays. Compared with differentiated cell types, stem cells expressed a significantly higher number of genes (represented by expressed sequence tags) whose functions are unknown. Murine and human hematopoietic stem cells were found to share a number of expressed gene products, which define key conserved regulatory pathways in this developmental system. This overlapping set of gene products represents a molecular signature of stem cells. The molecular attributes include 1) active JAK/STAT (Janus kinase/signal transducers and activators of transcription), TGF-ß, Yes (Yamaguchi sarcoma) kinase, and Notch signaling; 2) capacity to sense growth hormone and thrombin; 3) interaction with the extracellular matrix via integrin 6/1, Adam 9, and bystin; 4) engagement in the cell cycle, either arrested in G1 or cycling; 5) high resistance to stress, with upregulated DNA repair, protein folding, ubiquitin system, and detoxifier systems; 6) a remodeled chromatin, acted upon by DNA helicases, DNA methylases, and histone deacetylases; and 7) translation regulated by RNA helicases (120, 223). In embryonic neuroepithelial stem cells (NEP) and progenitors microarrays a few genes appeared to be present exclusively in NEP and not in progenitor cells, e.g., Frizzled 9, Sox-2. The following genes appeared to be enriched in neuronal (e.g., CDK5, neuropilin, EphB2, FGF11) or glial (e.g., CXCR4, RhoC, CD44, tenascin C) precursors (159). These results open a number of potential discoveries in neural stem biology; the potential of these findings is illustrated by the recent observations that the protein tyrosine phosphatase receptor type Z (PTPRZ), an enriched gene in adult NSCs data set (223), is critical for MS and EAE pathology. Harroch et al. (101), using PTPRZ-/- mice, demonstrated that these animals show impaired recovery from EAE and increased apoptosis of mature oligodendrocytes. More importantly in MS, this gene is expressed in remyelinating oligodendrocytes, suggesting a link with remyelinating progenitors cells (101).
| RESPONSES OF PROGENITORS CELLS DURING DEMYELINATION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
It was demonstrated some time ago that exogenous NSCs in the adult neocortex will give rise solely to glia (the developmentally appropriate response), unless there is a site of neuronal apoptotic death, in which case they will then switch their differentiation fate to yield the missing neurons (252), a program usually played out only during fetal corticogenesis. Furthermore, an incremental response in the form of proliferation and migration of SVZ cells toward lesions was reported (121, 260, 295). Nestin immunoreactivity in the SVZ is increased after injury, and these nestin-positive cells differentiate into astrocytes (105) and possibly into neurons in an experimental model of dopaminergic neurodegeneration (127). Ependymal stem cells migrate out of the central canal and differentiate into astrocytes in response to longitudinal fasciculus injury (75); whereas experimental cortical lesions increase the proliferation and induce expression of PS-NCAM in the SVZ (260). Finally, Magavi et al. (161) found that experimental targeted neuronal apoptosis induced a small degree of de novo cortical neurogenesis, possibly from SVZ precursors, in adult mice CNS. Others found that after injury in the hippocampus, there is increased generation of functional neurons from precursor cells (194) that participate in behavioral learning response (245). Hence, the microenvironment after injury may control the fate of adult stem cells by reinvoking developmental programs and generating new cells that may actively participate in neural circuitry (254).
Endogenous Progenitor Responses During Demyelination
Several models of experimental demyelination have been used: X-irradiation, chemical induced (lysolecithin, ethidium bromide, cuprizone), viral-induced demyelination, mutant myelin strains and immune mediate demyelination (74, 104). In the study of repair mechanism, the use of a reductionist focused model has the advantage of separating the components of the disease; however, to study progenitors and repair during MS will require the use of a model that closely resemble several aspects of the disease in humans. EAE, an animal model of MS, is characterized by an infiltration in the CNS of autoreactive T cells and macrophages, accompanied by the production of pro-inflammatory Th1 cytokines (118) and oxidative injury mediators (106). Similar to MS, EAE is an inflammatory, demyelinating disorder in which several pathological and clinical aspects are reproduced, namely, axonal damage, neuronal dysfunction and apoptosis, disruption of the blood-brain barrier (BBB), astrocytosis, prominent inflammatory infiltrate, demyelinating lesions, and remitting relapsing course of the disease (135, 294). These pathological aspects should be investigated in the context of endogenous and exogenous repair and cannot be replicated with more restricted models, such as chemically induced demyelination or with X-irradiation in which there is a limited inflammatory response. In addition, EAE, due to the close correlation of the clinical course of the disease with the subjacent pathology, has served as a screening tool for potential therapies that are now clinically useful (309). In fact NSCs injections have been shown to have an impact in the clinical score of EAE (213). Another beneficial aspect of EAE as a model for studying repair is the existence of several types of induction protocols that have different clinical and pathological severity but yet preserve the inflammatory demyelinating nature of the disease.
During the course of EAE, there is increased proliferation of cells in the SVZ, suggesting that stem or progenitor cells in this area may proliferate in response to inflammation/demyelination (34). Picard-Riera et al. (211) extended these observations to a chronic model of EAE, where they demonstrated proliferation of cells from the SVZ, migration to the corpus callosum, and differentiation to astrocytes and a small number of oligodendrocytes. Furthermore, using a model of EAE combined with either injection of MOG antibodies to induce inflammatory demyelination or nonspecific mouse immunoglobulins to induce an inflammatory response without demyelination, Di Bello et al. (58) suggested that remyelination by OPCs appears to be associated more closely with demyelination than with inflammation. However, the greater increase in OPC in inflammatory demyelinating lesions compared with those induced by anti-Gal-C antibodies suggests a mitogenic role for cytokines and growth factors released during inflammation (128). It is possible that the inflammatory environment is an important component of the engagement of the endogenous and exogenous progenitors (34, 58).
Several models of experimental demyelination have shown that spontaneous remyelination by precursor cells occurs (24). In a lysolecithin-induced demyelination model, progenitor cells of the adult mouse SVZ proliferate, migrate, and differentiate into oligodendrocytes (191, 204). Other groups have confirmed these results with retrovirus labeling of proliferating cells, demonstrating that endogenous progenitors in the subcortical white matter migrate and engage in repair of the lesion (42, 43, 84). Recently, Calza et al. (33), demonstrated that the SVZ cells can be redirected toward oligodendroglial differentiation with the administration of thyroid hormone (T4). T4 administration reduces cell proliferation and nestin expression in the SVZ and upregulates the expression of markers for oligodendrocyte progenitors O4, A2B5, and mature oligodendrocytes in the spinal cord, olfactory bulb, and SVZ. These findings provide a potential molecular target to influence the differentiation of stem cells and oligodendrocyte progenitors into myelinating cells.
Exogenous Progenitor Responses To Demyelination
The prospect of using transplants of NSCs and progenitors during demyelination requires an understanding of the behavior of these cells in experimental models. This would provide information about the interaction between the damaged host and the NSCs (205, 252). Several groups have used this approach to show that NSCs and OPCs can differentiate into mature oligodendrocytes. For instance, injection of murine NSC in the neonatal SVZ of dysmyelinated shiverer (shi) mice results in widespread oligodendrocyte differentiation with myelination of 40% of the host neuronal process in regions of engraftment with evident clinical improvement (297). EGF-responsive NSCs also have shown efficacy and oligodendrocyte differentiation when transplanted into the thoracolumbar region of md rats (96) and the shaking (Sh) pup canine myelin mutant (96, 179). Nestin-positive human neural precursor cells removed from surgical specimens have been used to induce repair in rat spinal cord with extensive remyelination (4). Even ES cells differentiate into oligodendrocytes and myelinate in culture and after spinal cord transplantation in shi mice (151) and md rat (28).
Transplanted OPCs were able to repair focal demyelinated areas in the neonatal and adult canine mutant (8). In the md mutant rat, carrying a mutation in PLP, injection of OPCs results in myelin formation in a wide distribution in the host parenchyma (66), and these cells can be isolated from the rat SVZ as well and produce robust myelin after transplantation (305). Some progenitors isolated from the SVZ require in vitro pre-induction to an oligodendroglial lineage to achieve myelination in vivo (247). Other cells such as olfactory ensheathing cells (OECs) and Schwann cells have been proposed as useful cells for myelin repair. Purified populations of human OECs have extremely high viability in tissue culture and are capable of remyelinating persistently demyelinated CNS axons and of induction of axonal regeneration (113), following transplantation into experimentally induced demyelinating lesions in the rat spinal cord (11, 126). In addition, Schwann cells have been used for transplantation into demyelinated areas; Schwann cells derived from human sural nerve were transplanted into the X-irradiation/ethidium bromide-lesioned dorsal columns of rats showing extensive remyelination, engraftment, and improved conduction velocity by electrophysiology analysis several weeks postransplantation (11, 113). These results indicate that several types of progenitors and even Schwann cell may be used for therapy and that they receive environmental cues that drive their migration and differentiation toward oligodendrocyte lineage (74). However, the selection of a particular cell type will require extensive experimentation and careful consideration of other factors such as source of isolation, in vitro manipulation, and ethical issues. Finally, the use of immature multipotent progenitors may be more beneficial considering that NSCs cannot only replace neurons and oligodendrocytes, but serve as modulators of the microenvironment by their ability to release growth factors even without transgenic manipulation (213).
These results suggest that demyelinating microenvironment may be able to engage exogenous and endogenous progenitor cells to become effectively myelinating cells. However, more information on the behavior the exogenous NSCs and OPCs in a deleterious environment like EAE is needed.
| MOLECULAR MEDIATORS INVOLVED IN NEURAL PROGENITOR RESPONSES DURING DEMYELINATION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
is upregulated during EAE and MS (219) and can mediate OPC apoptosis in vitro (35). TNF-
also potentiates the apoptotic effects of IFN-
on OPC cells, and this effect is partially reversible by caspase inhibitors (6). TNF-
reduces the expression of transcriptional regulators of survival and differentiation, namely peroxisome proliferator activator receptors (PPARs), especially PPAR
(54). The effects of TNF-
in vivo may be more complex; mice that lack TNF-
or the TNF-
receptor-2 (TNFR2) exhibit less remyelination than mice lacking TNF-
receptor 1 (TNFR1) in a model of cuprizone-induced demyelination, suggesting a long-term requirement of TNF-
in the proliferation of OPCs (9). Thus there may be a dual role for TNF-
, where an increase in TNF-
during the acute phase may be deleterious as observed in experimental brain injury (234). IFN-
and lipopolysaccharide induce apoptosis of mature oligodendrocytes and OPC via endogenous nitric oxide production (181), an effect that can be also obtained by cocultures of OPCs with activated microglial cells (207), probably through Toll-like receptor-4 (TLR4) (140). In vivo microglial activation is deleterious to oligodendrocyte progenitors (307), and microgliosis was observed in association with irradiation-induced neurogenesis dysfunction in the hippocampus (183), pointing to the importance of the environment for the fate of neural precursor cells. Infiltrating immune cells are a source of glutamate and can induce damage by excitotoxicity (209, 210). Glutamate receptor AMPA-mediated excitotoxicity is an independent and additional source of oligodendrocyte and axonal damage in EAE (212) and has been shown to induce apoptosis of mature differentiating oligodendrocytes (170, 212). Excitotoxicity may cause damage to other progenitors and NSCs as well, since both multipotent uncommitted and committed progenitors express functional AMPA receptors (81). Furthermore, glutamate agonists induce growth arrest and inhibit oligodendrocyte progenitor differentiation (82).
Oligodendrocytes and adult OPCs of adult rats are specifically susceptible to lytic effects of complement (292). However, there are other potential damaging mechanisms for NSC and progenitors during demyelinating injury, such as the expression of molecules that may render these cells immunogenic to the attack of T or B cells; IFN-
induces the expression of class I major histocompatibility complex molecule (MHC-I) on neural progenitors, thus making these cells potential targets during an immune response (10, 171). Cytokine-stimulated human immature neuroepithelial cell precursors express intercellular adhesion molecule 1 (ICAM-1) and interact with neutrophils by ICAM-1-LFA ligation (20). We have demonstrated that murine NSCs in vitro express MHC-I and functional CD80 and CD86 costimulatory molecules, which are upregulated after IFN-
stimulation and during stress-induced apoptosis (114). In summary, there is evidence to suggest that OPCs and NSCs may be vulnerable to inflammation, since they express receptors for various mediators of cell death. In vivo studies suggested that in some cases these cells may disappear during acute attacks of MS (50, 288). However, a systematic study of the dynamics of cell proliferation vs. cell death and its role in progression of the disease is still lacking.
Inability of Adult OPCs To Fully Differentiate Into Myelinating Oligodendrocytes
Data from MS pathology support a role for NSCs and progenitor cells in the pathogenesis of MS (217) (Fig. 4). The analysis of demyelinating lesions in MS during the chronic phase shows that a limited amount of remyelination occurs (229) and appears to be provided by migrating OPCs or NSCs that reside near the lesions. Some authors have shown that MS lesions contain a significant number of quiescent OPCs (286, 287). Using PDGF
receptor as a marker, Scolding et al. (236) have identified OPCs in the CNS of normal adults and of MS patients. Others have identified a relatively quiescent population of OPCs expressing NG2. These OPCs have been observed in lesions of patients with all the clinical subtypes of MS (50). In the chronic stages of the disease, most immature oligodendrocytes did not appear to be engaged in myelination (50), suggesting that oligodendrocyte differentiation of precursor cells is impaired in chronic MS, which is consistent with the general failure of myelin repair observed during the later stages of this disease (289).
|
Lack of Appropriate Molecular Signals from Destroyed Axons and Neurons
Normal axons and neurons produce signals that induce oligodendroglial differentiation (31, 156). Neurons, oligodendrocytes and astrocytes not only form an anatomical unit that maintains the nerve transmission, they also maintain a reciprocal paracrine loop between axons, myelin, and oligodendrocyte (174). However, immunologic attacks severely affect the integrity of this unit (174) (Fig. 4). OPCs are influenced by the axonal and neuronal environment through both diffusible and contact-mediated signals such as the neuregulins, PDGF
and PDGFß, and the FGFs (69, 100, 303). In active and chronic active MS lesions, astrocyte-derived neuregulin is dramatically reduced (279). During the course of MS, there is evidence for neuronal and axonal damage (23, 135, 177, 248), in addition to white matter abnormalities, that can jeopardize the ability for neurons to maintain oligodendrocytes homeostasis; this phenomenon may contribute to the absence of OPC full differentiation (40, 57, 135). Recent work by Trapp and colleagues (49) suggest that the lack of a physical substrate, a normal axon, is an obstacle for terminal differentiation of PLP-positive premyelinating oligodendrocytes. Thus some OPCs may survive the initial nonpermissive milieu and progress to more differentiated cells; however, the lack of a complete normal axon could be a sufficient obstacle for further differentiation.
Myelin itself can inhibit the maturation of OPCs in a concentration-dependent manner, suggesting an effect from membrane-associated proteins. Furthermore, axonal regeneration may be inhibited by molecules from injured oligodendrocytes and myelin exerting negative signals. Thus the potential neuronal self-repair and axonal regenerative mechanisms maybe contravened by negative signals released during myelin destruction. A molecule like NOGO-A with known inhibitory effects on axonal regeneration is released after traumatic myelin and oligodendrocytes injury (51, 91, 110). However, it is not known whether these molecules are released during MS flares nor whether these are responsible for the failure of remyelination in MS. It is likely that several complementary mechanisms contribute to the lack of remyelination in MS (49).
Inhibitory Effects of Molecules Released by Reactive Astrocytes
The lack of remyelination in MS may result in part from the suppressive effects of gliotic astrocytes on myelin formation. EAE and MS lesions are characterized by an increase in astrocyte reactivity demonstrated by hypertrophy and increase in the expression of GFAP but not astrocyte proliferation, despite the fact that MBP peptides are mitogenic in vitro for astrocytes (255). In vivo and in vitro experiments have shown that an astrocytic environment is not permissive for migration of OPCs or for axonal regrowth (68). Reactive astrocytes limit the remyelination capacity of Schwann cells injected into the CNS (25, 241). Furthermore, in MS patients, Schwann cell remyelination is seen in spinal cord lesions in areas that are devoid of astroglial scar (119) (Fig. 4, B and C). In vitro data support these in vivo observations: astrocyte explants were shown to inhibit axonal myelination (117).
Interestingly, astrocytes can activate Notch1 receptor on oligodendrocyte precursors via the ligand Jagged-1, which inhibits maturation of these cells. This activation can be mediated by TGF-ß1, a cytokine that is upregulated in MS. In vivo, Jagged-1 expression was high in hypertroph